Perm — three eras: Finno-Ugric shaman with drum + Stroganov salt merchant + Diaghilev with ballerina

Perm — A City of Many Lives

B1 · Elena Sova · ~90 min · reading · speaking · discussion · 20 sections
1

Warm-up — Perm in your head

4 questions · tap the audio button to listen
1
Have you ever heard about Perm? What do you know already?
2
Which cities do you know in the Ural region of Russia?
3
Would you rather explore an ice cave or a Soviet-era prison museum? Why?
4
Have you ever visited a city with several very different layers of history?

Predict the topic

Three words. What is today about?

Kama river
salt merchants
Diaghilev
2

Vocabulary — tap a card to flip

14 key words · tap to see meaning and example
the Ural Mountains
n
mountain range dividing Europe and Asia
Perm sits on the west side of the Urals.
the Kama river
n
the great river that flows through Perm
The Kama joins the Volga near Kazan.
Finno-Ugric
adj
ancient peoples of northern Russia (Komi, Perm, Mansi)
The name "Perm" comes from a Finno-Ugric word.
shaman
n
a spiritual leader who talks to nature spirits
Ancient shamans used drums and animal figures.
animal style
n
ancient Perm bronze art — bird-men and animal spirits
Perm animal-style bronzes are 1500 years old.
salt
n
the mineral that made the Stroganovs rich
Solikamsk means "salt on the Kama".
merchant
n
a trader who buys and sells for profit
The Stroganov merchants funded Yermak's expedition.
wooden sculpture
n
religious statues carved from wood — unique to Perm
Perm wooden sculpture shows Christ with local faces.
cave
n
a natural hole under the earth
The Kungur Ice Cave is 5 km long.
geological period
n
a long time in Earth's history
The Perm Period ended 252 million years ago.
fossil
n
the remains of an ancient plant or animal in rock
Scientists find fossils in Perm rocks.
ballet
n
classical dance — Perm has one of Russia's best schools
Diaghilev grew up in Perm.
the gulag
n
Soviet system of labour camps
Perm-36 is the only preserved gulag museum in Russia.
Yuryatin
n
Pasternak's fictional name for Perm in "Doctor Zhivago"
Yuryatin is really Perm in the novel.
Fun fact about Perm

From 1940 to 1957 the city was called «Molotov» — renamed after Stalin's foreign minister Vyacheslav Molotov. It quietly got its historic name back after Stalin's death.

3

Practice — drop the word into the gap

click a word, then click a gap
Ural
Kama
Finno-Ugric
shaman
animal
salt
sculpture
cave
period
Yuryatin

1. The Mountains divide Europe from Asia.

2. The river flows through the city of Perm.

3. The ancient tribes of the region were peoples.

4. A was a spiritual leader who talked to nature spirits.

5. The famous Perm style shows bronze bird-men with wings.

6. The Stroganov family became rich from mining in Solikamsk.

7. Wooden from Perm churches are unique in Russia.

8. The Kungur Ice is a natural wonder near Perm.

9. Scientists named a geological after the city of Perm.

10. Boris Pasternak turned Perm into the fictional town of in "Doctor Zhivago".

4

Reading — Five Things About Perm

read · listen · answer True / False / Not Stated
Panorama of Perm with the Kama river, railway bridge, and cathedral domes

Five Things You Didn't Know About Perm

Perm is not on the usual Russian tourist list, but it should be. Here are five reasons why.

1
A geological period is named after this city. In 1841, a British geologist called Roderick Murchison came to the Urals and gave the world a new word — the "Permian Period" (299 to 252 million years ago). Every child on Earth who studies geology learns the name of Perm.
2
The city's name is older than Russia. "Perm" comes from a Finno-Ugric word that meant "far-away land". Long before Slavs arrived, Komi and Mansi peoples lived here and made bronze figures of bird-men and animal spirits — the famous Perm animal style.
3
Salt built the city. In the 16th century the Stroganov merchant family started to mine salt near Perm. They became so rich that they paid for Yermak's expedition to conquer Siberia. Without Stroganov salt, there would be no Russian Siberia.
4
Perm invented Russian ballet — twice. Sergei Diaghilev grew up in Perm; later he took Russian ballet to Paris and shocked Europe. During World War II, the Kirov (now Mariinsky) ballet company from Leningrad was evacuated to Perm — and stayed for three years, teaching a whole generation of local dancers.
5
Only preserved gulag museum in Russia. Perm-36, about 100 km east of the city, is the only Soviet labour camp that still stands as a museum. Boris Pasternak also disguised Perm as the fictional town of "Yuryatin" in his novel Doctor Zhivago.
Audio 01

True / False / Not Stated

1. A whole geological period is named after the city of Perm.
2. The name "Perm" comes from a Slavic word.
3. The Stroganovs paid for Yermak's expedition to Siberia.
4. The Kirov ballet company stayed in Perm for ten years.
5. Perm-36 is the only preserved gulag museum in Russia today.

Speaking

?
Which of the 5 facts surprised you the most?
?
Which of the four «lives» of Perm — Finno-Ugric, Stroganov, Soviet, or modern cultural — is the most interesting for you?
5

Bridge — Yermak and the Stroganov salt empire

short story · listen and answer
Stroganov merchant handing a charter to the Cossack ataman Yermak, salt-mining scene in the background

In the sixteenth century, the Stroganov family was the richest merchant family in Russia. They controlled the salt mines around Solikamsk, and salt in those days was as valuable as oil is today.

To the east of their lands, beyond the Ural mountains, there was Siberia — huge, cold, full of fur, but also full of hostile tribes and raiders. The Stroganovs needed protection.

So in 1581 they hired a Cossack ataman called Yermak. They gave him weapons, food, boats, and a written charter — and sent him east with a small army. Yermak crossed the Urals, defeated the Siberian Khanate, and opened Siberia for the Russian Empire.

Without Stroganov salt, there would have been no money for Yermak. Without Yermak, there would have been no Russian Siberia. It all started here, near Perm.

Audio 02

Simple questions

1
What made the Stroganov family so rich?
2
Why was salt so valuable in the 16th century?
3
Who did the Stroganovs hire to protect their lands?
4
What did Yermak do after crossing the Urals?

Let's talk

A
Do you think it was right for the Stroganovs to hire a Cossack army to expand into Siberia? Why or why not?
B
What resource today is as valuable as salt was in the 16th century?
Fun fact about Perm

Diaghilev grew up in Perm. The future star of the Paris Ballet went to school in his grandmother's house on Sibirskaya Street — the building is now the Diaghilev Gymnasium and a museum.

6

Can you ask these questions?

practise asking about Perm · word order

Words are shuffled — say the question in the correct order. Click any word to hear it.

1.7 words → 1 question
2.5 words
3.7 words
4.5 words
5.4 words
6.5 words · to visit Perm
7.7 words
8.6 chunks (indirect question!)
7

Listening — why people come to Perm today

listen · answer
Audio 03

Three modern tourists explain why they came to Perm.

Kungur Ice Cave with blue-lit ice stalactites

NNature lovers

For nature lovers, Perm means the Kungur Ice Cave — 5 kilometres of underground grottoes lit up in blue — and rafting down the wild Chusovaya river in summer.

Wooden salt-mining towers of Solikamsk in winter

HHistory fans

For history fans, Perm means the old Stroganov salt towns of Solikamsk and Cherdyn, and the sombre Perm-36 gulag memorial — the only preserved Soviet camp in Russia.

Diaghilev House Museum in Perm at dusk with warm-lit windows

AArt lovers

For art lovers, Perm means the Diaghilev Festival every summer, the world-famous Perm Opera and Ballet, and the unique wooden sculpture and animal-style bronze collections.

Questions

1
Why do nature lovers come to Perm?
2
How long is the Kungur Ice Cave?
3
Which town is famous for old salt towers?
4
Why is the Perm-36 memorial unique in Russia?
5
Name two things that art lovers can see in Perm.
8

Places to visit in Perm — match them

5 places · 5 descriptions

Click a place name (top), then click the matching drop here next to its description.

Kungur Ice Cave
Solikamsk
Perm-36
Diaghilev House
Perm Opera
drop here
One of the largest ice caves in Russia — 5 km of underground grottoes with huge ice stalactites, lit up in cold blue. Just 90 km from Perm.
drop here
The old salt-mining town north of Perm. Stroganov salt towers still stand — this was the source of the family's wealth and, indirectly, of Russian Siberia.
drop here
The only preserved Soviet gulag memorial in Russia. Wooden barracks, watchtowers and barbed wire stand exactly as they did in the 1970s.
drop here
A 19th-century mansion on Sibirskaya Street where young Sergei Diaghilev lived. Now a museum of his life and of the Ballets Russes.
drop here
The Perm Opera and Ballet Theatre — one of the oldest in Russia. Home of the annual Diaghilev Festival and Teodor Currentzis's MusicAeterna.

Speaking

A
Which of these five Perm places would you most like to visit? Why?
B
Have you ever heard about the Perm-36 memorial before today? How do you feel about visiting a former labour camp?
C
Is it possible for one city to be famous for nature (a cave), industry (salt), tragedy (a gulag) and art (ballet) at the same time?
Fun fact about Perm

The famous red letters «Счастье не за горами» on the Kama embankment became a national meme after artist Boris Matrosov installed them in 2009. They literally mean «Happiness is not far away» — a pun on «горы» (mountains) and the Urals right behind you.

10

Dialogue — tourist meets a Perm guide

Brian (guide) + Emma (tourist)
Audio 04▶ tap any bubble below to hear that line (Brian / Emma voices)
EM
Hi, are you Brian? I booked the one-day Perm tour.
BR
Yes, that's me. Lovely to meet you, Emma. Have you been to Perm before?
EM
No, never. Honestly, I only knew the name because of the Permian Period at school.
BR
That's a great start. Most tourists have no idea a whole geological period is named after our city.
EM
Could you tell me what we'll see today?
BR
Of course. We'll walk along the Kama embankment, visit the Perm animal-style bronze collection at the art gallery, then take a car to Kungur Ice Cave. In the evening — a concert at the Opera House.
EM
How far is Kungur? Would we have time to also see the Diaghilev House?
BR
Kungur is about 90 kilometres — roughly ninety minutes each way. If we skip the cave, we could do the Diaghilev House and even Perm-36. But that's a lot for one day.
EM
Would you rather go to the cave or to Perm-36?
BR
Personally — Perm-36. The cave is beautiful, but the gulag memorial is something you cannot see anywhere else in Russia.
EM
Then let's do Perm-36 in the morning and the concert in the evening. Perfect.

Questions

1
What is the ONLY thing Emma knew about Perm before this trip?
2
What was Brian's first suggested plan for the day?
3
How long does it take to get from Perm to Kungur (one way)?
4
Why does Brian personally prefer Perm-36 over the cave?
11

"Would" — quick base

three ways to use would
UseStructureExample
Polite wishI would like + noun / to-verbI would like to visit the Kungur Ice Cave.
Choice of twoWould you rather + verb + or + verb?Would you rather see Perm-36 or the cave?
If…If + past, would + verbIf I had time, I would visit Solikamsk.
Common slips
I would to visitI would visit · I would like to visit
Would you rather to go?Would you rather go?
If I will have timeIf I had time

Mini check — finish the sentence

1
I would ___ to visit the Diaghilev House one day. (polite wish)
2
Would you ___ go to Kungur in the morning or in the evening? (choice of two)
3
If I ___ more time, I ___ visit Solikamsk. (if + past, would + verb)
12

Would you rather — Perm edition

answer in a full sentence + 2 reasons
1. Would you rather visit the Kungur Ice Cave or the Perm-36 gulag memorial?
Need a hint?

Kungur Ice Cave — 5 km of underground grottoes lit up in blue. Cold, magical, purely natural. Great for photos.

Perm-36 — a real Soviet labour camp preserved as a memorial. Heavy, silent, historically important. Not «pleasant», but unforgettable.

2. Would you rather try Ural pelmeni or Kama river fish soup (ukha)?
Need a hint?

Pelmeni — small meat dumplings from the Ural region, often eaten with sour cream and vinegar. Filling, cosy, winter food.

Ukha — clear river-fish soup with potatoes, onion and dill. Light, seasonal, best in summer.

3. Would you rather walk along the Kama embankment or through the wooden sculpture museum first?
Need a hint?

Kama embankment — 4 km of open river views, the famous red letters "Счастье не за горами", bicycles, sunsets. Public and free.

Wooden sculpture museum — silent gallery of life-size Christ figures with Komi faces. Intense, dark, deeply Perm.

4. Would you rather see Perm in white winter or in green summer?
Need a hint?

Winter — deep snow, frozen Kama, the ice cave at its most dramatic. Very cold — often minus 20.

Summer — Kama boat trips, Chusovaya rafting, White Nights, but mosquitoes in the forest.

5. Would you rather sleep in a modern hotel in the centre or in a wooden guesthouse in Solikamsk?
Need a hint?

Modern hotel — nice room, hot shower, ten minutes from the Opera House. Comfortable but ordinary.

Wooden guesthouse in Solikamsk — old Stroganov merchant town, homemade breakfast, but 200 km from Perm.

6. Would you rather visit Perm with a local historian or with a young art curator?
Need a hint?

Local historian — Stroganov era, salt mines, gulag, Civil War. Deep facts, lots of dates.

Young curator — Diaghilev Festival, PERMM contemporary art, street art. Modern, cool, less history.

7. Would you rather see Perm in one day or in one whole week?
Need a hint?

One day — embankment + wooden sculpture museum + a concert. You catch the highlights, but everything feels rushed.

One whole week — Kungur, Solikamsk, Perm-36, Diaghilev House, a Chusovaya boat trip. You go deeper but need more time and money.

Sentence starters: I would rather… because… · I'd prefer to… since… · Honestly, I'd choose… because…
13

Modal verbs — optional

expand if time
Expand · 8 tasks on must / should / might / could
ModalMeaningExample
muststrong obligationYou must book Perm-36 in advance.
mustn'tprohibitionYou mustn't touch the wooden sculptures.
shouldadviceYou should take a warm jacket to Kungur.
mightpossibilityIt might snow in May.
couldpossibility / polite requestWe could start at the embankment.

A Tourist's First Day in Perm · choose the modal:

1. When you arrive, you ___ feel that Perm is bigger than you expected.
2. You ___ start at the Kama embankment for the best view.
3. You ___ touch the wooden sculptures — they are 300 years old.
4. The temperature in Kungur Ice Cave ___ be below zero even in July.
5. You ___ try local pelmeni — they are much better than in Moscow.
6. We ___ take a taxi to Perm-36 — the bus takes 3 hours.
7. After the cave, you ___ feel cold — bring hot tea.
8. By the end of the day, you ___ feel that Perm is unlike any other Russian city.
Fun fact about Perm

Kungur Ice Cave (2 hours from Perm) has 58 grottoes and 70 underground lakes. The ice stays year-round — even in July it's −2 °C inside. One of the largest karst caves in Russia.

14

Speaking — three levels

Safe → Guided → Freer

A · Safe practice 2-3 min

Short answers using lesson vocabulary.

1
Where does the name "Perm" come from?
2
Name two things that made the Stroganov family famous.
3
What is a shaman?
4
Why is Perm-36 unique in Russia?
5
What is Yuryatin, and why does Perm care about it?

B · Guided 8-10 min

Repeat the 7 "Would you rather" prompts from section 12 — now spoken aloud. Full sentence + 2 reasons.

Honestly, I'd rather… because… · I'd find it more meaningful to… · If I had the choice, I'd pick… because…

C · Freer 10-15 min

Choose 2 prompts and speak for 2-3 minutes on each.

Why is Perm not on the usual tourist list, even though it has so many unique things?
If you could meet Diaghilev, a Stroganov merchant, or Pasternak — who would you choose and why?
Should a small provincial city try to become a cultural capital, or should culture live only in Moscow and Saint Petersburg?
What's one place in your own life that has "many lives" — several different histories layered on top of each other?
Imagine you have to describe Perm to a friend in 3 sentences. What would you say?
What strikes me most is… · I'd argue that… · From my perspective… · On the other hand…
15

Three famous people from Perm

Diaghilev · the Stroganovs · Pasternak
Portrait of Sergei Diaghilev

DSergei Diaghilev

Who: impresario, founder of the Ballets Russes.

Did: brought Russian ballet to Paris in 1909, worked with Nijinsky, Stravinsky, Picasso, Coco Chanel.

Stroganov merchant patriarch, 17th-century parsuna portrait

SThe Stroganovs

Who: the richest merchant family of the 16th–17th centuries.

Did: controlled the salt mines of Solikamsk, financed Yermak's expedition, opened Siberia for the Russian Empire.

Boris Pasternak on the Kama river embankment in Perm

PBoris Pasternak

Who: Nobel-Prize-winning poet and novelist.

Did: lived in Perm during the Civil War; disguised it as the fictional town of «Yuryatin» in "Doctor Zhivago".

Speaking

1
Which of the three names did you know before today? Where did you hear it?
2
Which of the three left the biggest mark on the world — art (Diaghilev), business (Stroganovs), or literature (Pasternak)?
3
If Perm were a person, which one of the three would fit its character best? Why?
16

Discussion — identity of a Russian city

if time allows
Can one city really be famous for four different things — nature, salt, gulag and ballet — at the same time? Or does one identity always win?
Is it right to make a museum out of a former labour camp? What are the pros and cons of Perm-36?
Perm calls itself "the cultural capital of the Urals". What does a city have to prove to earn this title?
If Perm sat on a warm sea instead of on the Kama, would it still be the same city? Why or why not?
Every Russian city has its own myth. What is Perm's myth, in one sentence?
Fun fact about Perm

Perm-36 — the last political prison camp of the Soviet Union — is the only preserved Gulag site in Russia. Today it works as a memorial museum, 120 km from Perm.

17

Review · self-check

no homework

Quick review

1
Give a word for "green Ural stone with wavy patterns" → ?
2
Give a word for "a trader who buys and sells for profit" → ?
3
Word order: have / you / ever / been / to / Perm / ? → ?
4
Correct this question: "Where Kungur is?" → ?
5. I would ___ to visit the Diaghilev House someday.
6. If I ___ in Perm, I would go to the Kama embankment every evening.
7. Perm is a very unusual city, ___ ?

Self-check

A
What was easy today?
B
What was difficult?
C
What should we practise again next time?
18

Beauty from the Urals — malachite, salt, birchbark

world-famous beauty secrets · vocab + reading + speaking
Ural crafts flat lay: malachite jewellery box, salt crystal, birchbark box, Kasli cast-iron figurine

The Ural mountains have been a natural workshop for centuries. Four crafts made the region famous around the world.

Malachite. This green stone with wavy patterns is mined in the Urals. Since the 18th century it has been used for jewellery boxes, table tops and even entire church columns. The Malachite Room in the Winter Palace in Saint Petersburg is built from Ural malachite.

Salt. White salt crystals from Solikamsk built the fortune of the Stroganov merchants — and, indirectly, opened Siberia. Even today, some souvenir shops in Perm sell raw salt crystals in glass jars.

Birch bark. Light, waterproof and beautiful, birch bark has been used by Komi and Russian craftsmen for a thousand years to make bread boxes, small chests and jewellery. Modern designers still use it.

Kasli cast iron. In the town of Kasli, just south of Perm Krai, craftsmen learned to cast delicate lace-like iron figurines in the 19th century. Kasli iron won a gold medal at the World Exhibition in Paris in 1900.

Vocabulary — tap a card to flip

malachite
n
green Ural stone with wavy patterns
The box is made of Ural malachite.
birch bark
n
outer skin of a birch tree, used for craft
A birch-bark box keeps bread fresh.
cast iron
n
iron shaped in a mould — Kasli is famous for lace-like cast iron
Kasli cast iron won gold in Paris 1900.
craft
n
a skilled art made by hand
Wooden sculpture is a Ural craft.
craftsman
n
a person skilled in a craft
Ural craftsmen carve wooden saints.
jewellery box
n
small decorated box for rings and necklaces
The malachite jewellery box shines green.
souvenir
n
a small object you bring home from a trip
A salt crystal is my Perm souvenir.
Pavel Bazhov
n
Ural writer whose tales made malachite legendary
Bazhov's "The Malachite Box" is a classic.
Perm animal-style bronze bird-man figurine on dark studio background

True / False

1. Malachite is a green stone from the Urals.
2. Birch bark is used to make big columns for palaces.
3. Kasli cast iron won a gold medal at the 1900 Paris Exhibition.
4. The Malachite Room in the Winter Palace uses Ural stone.

Mini discussion — crafts & souvenirs

1. Which of the four Ural crafts would you buy as a souvenir? Why?
2. Do you have any handmade items at home? What are they and where are they from?
3. Is it important to you that a souvenir is made in the place you visited, not in China?
4. Would you rather learn a traditional craft yourself or just buy the finished piece?
5. In fifty years, will young people in Russia still know what malachite or birch bark is?
Sentence starters: I would buy… because… · For me the most beautiful is… · I think crafts will survive because…
19

Perm today — Currentzis, Diaghilev Festival & more

"cultural capital of the Urals" · reading + speaking
Teodor Currentzis conducting MusicAeterna at the Perm Opera House

In the last twenty years Perm has quietly become the cultural capital of the Urals. It's still an industrial city on the Kama, but three things have put it on the international map.

First — the Diaghilev Festival. Every June, the Perm Opera House hosts one of the biggest classical-music events in Russia: opera, ballet, symphonic concerts, night marathons.

Second — Teodor Currentzis and his orchestra MusicAeterna, based in Perm for many years. Currentzis's recordings of Mozart and Tchaikovsky won prizes in Europe and America.

Third — a wave of modern museums and street art. The Museum of Contemporary Art PERMM, the giant red letters «Счастье не за горами» on the Kama embankment ("Happiness is not far away"), and Perm Zoo — one of the oldest zoos in Russia.

Perm Opera and Ballet Theatre at night

OPerm Opera

The Perm Opera and Ballet Theatre, one of the oldest in Russia. Home of the annual Diaghilev Festival and the MusicAeterna orchestra.

Perm wooden sculpture of Christ with local features

MWooden Sculpture Museum

Inside the old Spaso-Preobrazhenskaya Cathedral: dozens of life-size wooden saints with local Komi faces. Nothing like it anywhere else.

Kama river embankment at sunset — Perm, with cast-iron balustrade, lanterns and 'Кама · наша гордость' sign

KKama Embankment

The 4-km Kama embankment is Perm's living room. Bicycles, sunset views of the bridge, and the famous red letters "Счастье не за горами".

Key vocabulary

festival conductor orchestra opera contemporary art embankment cultural capital street art

Mini discussion — culture & identity

1. Why do you think a small industrial city like Perm needed a huge classical-music festival?
2. Which is more important for a Russian city today — new museums or old ones?
3. Have you ever been to a music festival? What do you remember most?
4. Is it possible for street art like "Happiness is not far away" to change how people feel about their city?
5. Would you rather spend an evening at the Diaghilev Festival or on the Kama embankment at sunset?
20

Sergei Diaghilev — the Perm boy who conquered Paris

from a wooden house on Sibirskaya Street to the Ballets Russes
Ballets Russes 1909 Paris poster with Nijinsky in 'Le Spectre de la Rose'

Sergei Diaghilev was born in Novgorod in 1872, but he grew up in Perm, in a large wooden house on Sibirskaya Street. His family loved music. They organised evening concerts, and little Sergei learned piano and singing from a very young age.

He was not a great composer or dancer himself. His talent was different — he saw talent in others, and he knew how to bring artists, musicians and dancers together to make something new.

In 1909, when he was thirty-seven, he brought a Russian ballet company to Paris. He called it "Les Ballets Russes". The first season shocked Europe. Paris had never seen dancers like Vaslav Nijinsky, sets by Léon Bakst, or music by young Igor Stravinsky.

For twenty years, until his death in 1929, Diaghilev's company travelled Europe. He worked with Picasso, Coco Chanel, Matisse and dozens more. He never went back to Russia after the Revolution.

Today the annual Diaghilev Festival in Perm brings the world's best dancers and orchestras home — to the same city where a music-loving boy once played piano in a wooden house.

Audio 05

Vocabulary: impresario — producer of shows · talent — natural ability · company — group of artists · season — series of shows · set / costume — stage design · composer — writer of music · legacy — what you leave behind.

True / False / Not Stated

1. Diaghilev was born in Perm.
2. Diaghilev himself was a great dancer.
3. The Ballets Russes first performed in Paris in 1909.
4. Diaghilev returned to Russia after the Revolution.
5. Picasso designed costumes for the Ballets Russes.

Mini discussion — talent & legacy

1. What is more valuable — being a great artist yourself, or being able to see and support talent in others?
2. Have you ever been to a ballet, opera or classical concert? What did you feel?
3. Why do you think a small provincial city like Perm produced someone like Diaghilev?
4. Is it important for a Russian artist today to be famous abroad, or is being famous only in Russia enough?
5. Would you rather meet young Diaghilev in Perm, or old Diaghilev in Paris? Why?
Sentence starters: For me, seeing talent in others is… · What surprises me is that… · I would rather meet… because…